Hana Kimi Taiwan (ABS-CBN) versus Hana Kimi Japan (GMA 7)
ABS-CBN and GMA Network is at it again. This time and for the first time, both networks will be airing two shows with the same title on March 24 but two different adaptations.
GMA Network is showing the Japanese adaption whereas ABS-CBN is showing the Taiwanese adaptation. Both series has its similarities: 3 main characters, a dog, a gay doctor, a photo journalist, the effeminate classmate, 3 dorms, and the crazy adventures. So which series is better? Some say that the Japanese version is way better, funny and heartwarming than the Taiwanese version. Some say the Taiwanese version is better because the lead male actor is more good-looking than the Japanese version. Then there’s some who say that ABS-CBN is better at dubbing compared to GMA. The viewers will ultimately be the judge to that.
sa mga nagsasabing panget c ella. fiy, c ella ang na vote ng mga tao sa taiwan as the most beautiful women , dala kaya xa sa top 100 models around d world, super talented bcoz she can act as well as mas sing. Sikat ang hana kimi taiwan sa negros occidental. i really love it… go ChunElla
i prefer HK taiwanese version, coz its a lot more funnier than the jap. ver. ive seen the jap. but sorry to say for all the fans of HK JAP, its not enjoyable to watch(own opinion).. i really like the way ella portrayed the character there.. its a job well done for her maybe sometimes her facial expression was too much but its one thing why i keep on watching it and also because of the 2 cute boys from fhrenheir wuchun and jiro wang .. in HK TIwan i enjoy every episode of it bec. the characters are blending.. so definitely my vote goes to HK TAIWAN
and also the chemistry between the 2 main characters were so good thats why i chose the taiwan ver. i love chunella! i hope there will be a sequel for hana kmi taiwan because everybody who loves the show is still hangin about the ending. ahm.. CE FANS do you think its possible CE in real life??
I bet on watching Hana Kimi in ABS yung Taiwanese version kasi funny tsaka bagay yung loveteam sana dito sa Bacolod yung TV Patrol Bacolod alisin na para walang salot kasi before mag Boy and Kris yung Hana Kimi pinapalabas dito e kainis last 6 episodes pa naman kasi paminsan putol putol yung episode kaya sana ilipat sa Primetime.hehehehehe sana si Ella makapunta dito fan pa naman ako ng S.H.E at Fahrenheit noh.!!!
i love hana kimi taiwan than japanese..wu chun-ella chen tandem is so cute…also jiro wang and danson tang is so handsome..hana kimi the repeat pls abs-cbn on primetime bida after singing bee plssssssssssssssss..!!!!!
tataas ratings nyo promise!!!
hay ashiya kung wala kang magawa sa sinasabi mo sumama kang lumangoy sa dyesebel na serinang lokaloka hahahahahah kakatawa talaga………baka maging ka lahi nya pero hindi ka serinang lokaloka kundi butanding……….hehehehehe.kakatawa talaga effects ng mga kangusong walang usong manggaya………..bleeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee.
AYAN NATAPOS NA ANG HANA KIMI TAIWAN SA ABS-CBN AT NAKAKUHA ITO NG 32.45% SA MEGA MANILA IN SHORT IT WAS NO#1…GO ABS-CBN
SANA ULITIN ITO SA PRIMETIME BIDA AND FOR SURE IT IS STILL NO#1
huuhh nakakaloka my girl num 1
Mas maganda yung Hana Kimi ng abs….mukhang luma yung sa gma…
Sana magkaroong ng hana kimi 2…
hana kimi taiwan ang bida!!!!!
panget nung japan!!!ganda lng nung ending kz inamin nya na girl xa!!!un lng inamin nya lng!!haha..
compared sa hkt…ms nkakatwa and mas gwapo ung mga cast!!
cnu ngsabi na panget c ella?
ganda nia kea!!!tska bgay s knya ung role…dhil nagmuka tlaga ciang boy unlike sa ashiya ng hkj….
team kapamilya tayo!!!!
Thank you everyone for making this article a success. Feel free to join other discussions by clicking HOT DISCUSSIONS on the NavBar.
Wahaha kakaawa naman ung mga nagpipilit na maganda ang hana kimi ng 7!!! ilan ba kayong nagsasabi nyan???? haha.. maganda pa din ang hana kimi taiwan version!! kahit saan mo ilagay na channel un, mas maganda pa din un!!! hahaha..
at generally, talaga namang original ang 2.. wag na i-consider ang standing eh.. pero mas magaling pa din gumawa ng mga palabas ang two.. and adding the fact that their the one who started airing asian series.. super gaya-gaya ang 7.. napaka-loser! pathetic kaya un!!!! hahaha.. SEVEN! LOSER!!!!
Okay kakatapos ko lang panoorin to ngayon and I must say na
HANA KIMI TAIWAN is the best! No wonder. Una, yung pagkaportray ng role ni ELLA bilang Rui Xi, talagang karapat dapat bigyan ng clap-clap. Di ako biased on their facial features (kasi madami nga nagsasabing mas gwapo mga bida sa taiwan vs. japan) pero sa kilos ni Ella vs Mizuki, lalaking lalaki si Ella. YUN TALAGA ANG NAGPAPANGGAP. Si Mizuki, bukod sa super ganda para maging lalake, wala man lang kaeffort effort. Tapos yung damit nya halata namang babae sya. WALA BANG CREATIVITY ang crew nila? Production Staffs?
Sunod sa storyline. Sobrang haba ng HANA KIMI T pero di man lang ako nabore panoorin every single scene. Against HANA KIMI J 12 eps lang ata pero may scenes na di ko talaga mapigilang magforward. Ang panget lang sa HKT eh yung ending! Dapat sasabihin na nya na babae sya kaso nauudlot lagi ng friends nila, instead sinabi nya na magpapaopera sya achuchuchu. Sa HKJ muntik akong mapaluha sa ending. PERO YUN LANG ang maganda dun.
Judging an idol drama shouldn’t be based on what channel it is broadcasted. Pano kung for example, Dae Jang Geum (Jewel in the Palace) which is the 2nd best korean drama of all time eh ibinroadcast sa ABS? Syempre mandidiri yung mga kapuso na “Eww ang bading ng palabas nyo”. Pero dahil sa GMA naman ipinalabas, proud pa sila na natalo nila ang PBB kahit diring diri na sila.
yung hana kimi ng abs-cbn the best kasi made on taiwan at may nakakatawa na parts at may creativity pa sila.yung taiwanese version,may sense yung mga sinasabi nla tapos may mga romance between brian zuo (wu chun) and joey (ella).d2 rn nkta n gs2 ni westley jin (jiro wang) kay joey (ella).kaea ms mgnda ang HANA KIMI TWNSE V. khesa s HANA KIMI JPNSE V.
i like thetaiwan version because. . . . . . MAS NAKAKAKILIG AT MAS NAKAKATAWA HAHAHAHAHAHAHA. . . . . unlyk japan hmp love qcla wu chun ellaand jiro!!!!! ZUNELLA FOReVER!!!